11-year-old to face trial for Karachi Gul Plaza fire that killed 72
An 11-year-old boy, identified as Huzaifa, is slated to face trial for allegedly starting the fire at Karachi's Gul Plaza Shopping Centre on January 17, which tragically resulted in 72 fatalities. The charge sheet was filed by the investigating officer (IO) on Saturday, with the approval of in-charge district prosecutor Abdul Razzaq Gujjar, despite earlier objections from another prosecutor who requested the inclusion of a judicial commission's report. Gujjar permitted the charge sheet's filing, stating the commission's report could be submitted later. The devastating fire also left eight people injured and destroyed 1,153 shops. Alongside Huzaifa, his father Naimatullah, owner of an artificial flower shop, and four members of the Gul Plaza Management Committee—Tanveer Pasta, Amar Ismail, Muhammad Ramazan, and Muhammad Ameen—are also named as accused and are currently absconding. The IO has listed 42 prosecution witnesses, with some providing statements to a judicial magistrate. One witness, 13-year-old Aryan, testified that Huzaifa was playing with matches when the fire erupted, a claim supported by two other eyewitnesses who stated Naimatullah frequently left his son in charge of the shop. Call data records indicate Naimatullah was not present at the time of the incident. The charge sheet alleges the management committee failed to take action against Naimatullah for allowing his underage son to operate the shop alone. Furthermore, the building's exits were reportedly locked or blocked, fire safety equipment was insufficient, and no fire hydrant system or emergency lighting was in place. Management committee members also allegedly failed to contact emergency services, demonstrating negligence. As Huzaifa is a minor, the case against him will proceed in juvenile court, while the other suspects face charges including negligence with fire, manslaughter, and mischief by fire under the Pakistan Penal Code.
The tragic fire at Gul Plaza highlights systemic failures in building safety and regulatory oversight. The prosecution's decision to proceed with a charge sheet for an 11-year-old, while also implicating management and the father, points to a complex web of accountability. The delay and procedural disputes in filing the charge sheet suggest potential challenges in gathering conclusive evidence or navigating legal complexities, particularly concerning juvenile culpability and corporate or management negligence. Future investigations and legal processes should focus on strengthening enforcement mechanisms for fire safety codes and ensuring that property management entities are held robustly accountable for maintaining safe environments. This incident underscores the critical need for proactive safety audits and clear lines of responsibility to prevent future loss of life and property, especially in densely populated commercial spaces.
AI-generated to prompt reflection — not editorial opinion, not advice, not a statement of fact. How this works.