Lawyers Convicted for Withholding Client Funds; Police Investigate Further Cases
A law firm in Campinas, Brazil, and its lawyers, José Antonio Cremasco and Thais Proença Cremasco, have been ordered to pay R$239,500 to a client who did not receive funds from a 2014 labor lawsuit. This decision, issued on Friday, March 3rd, is subject to appeal. The Civil Police are currently investigating the father-daughter legal team for alleged misappropriation of client funds in at least nine separate inquiries. One investigation was initiated in 2025 following a referral from the Public Prosecutor's Office of São Paulo State.
Thais Proença Cremasco claims her father, José Antonio Cremasco, was solely responsible for the alleged diversions, stating that he directed funds into specific accounts and handled client payments. She asserts she has not worked at her father's firm since 2024, having severed ties due to complaints from allegedly harmed workers. Conversely, José Antonio Cremasco blames his daughter, asserting she had complete control over both his business account and her personal account during the period of 2022 to 2024. He also notes that there are no reports of clients not receiving funds before 2022 or after 2025.
The Ordem dos Advogados do Brasil (OAB) confirmed Thais Proença Cremasco resigned from the São Paulo Sectional Council this year, and disciplinary proceedings are underway, kept under legal seal. The judge ruled that the lawyers' actions constituted a breach of contract and an unlawful act by withholding client funds beyond their agreed-upon fees. In addition to the R$239,500, the Cremascos were ordered to pay R$20,000 in moral damages.
This case highlights significant governance failures within a legal practice, leading to a civil judgment and criminal investigations. The conflicting accounts from father and daughter, each blaming the other for financial mismanagement and alleged misappropriation, underscore the critical need for robust internal controls and transparent financial practices in law firms. The involvement of multiple regulatory bodies, including the Civil Police and the OAB's disciplinary tribunal, suggests systemic issues that extend beyond a single dispute. Moving forward, such incidents prompt reflection on professional accountability mechanisms and the potential for conflicts of interest when familial relationships intersect with fiduciary duties, particularly in client trust fund management. The legal system's response will likely influence best practices for financial oversight in legal services.
AI-generated to prompt reflection — not editorial opinion, not advice, not a statement of fact. How this works.