Managers Withhold Positive Feedback From Employees, Especially Women, Study Finds
A recent study published in the journal Management Science reveals that a significant portion of managers, approximately one in four, refrain from providing performance feedback to their supervisees. This withholding occurs even when the feedback is positive. The research, conducted by a team from the University of Portsmouth, the University of Exeter, and York University, highlights a concerning trend in workplace communication. Performance feedback is recognized as essential for employees to make informed decisions regarding their career development and educational pursuits. The study specifically noted that this pattern of withholding feedback was more pronounced when dealing with female employees. This suggests a potential gender disparity in how feedback is delivered and received within managerial relationships. The implications of this finding could impact employee growth, motivation, and overall job satisfaction, particularly for women in the workforce.
The study's finding that managers withhold positive feedback, disproportionately affecting female employees, points to potential systemic issues in performance management and communication. This behavior, even when feedback is favorable, may stem from unconscious biases, a lack of training in effective feedback delivery, or organizational cultures that do not prioritize open communication. The long-term consequences could include stunted employee development, reduced engagement, and increased attrition, especially among demographics that receive less developmental support. Addressing this requires organizations to foster environments where constructive and positive feedback is consistently encouraged and delivered, alongside robust training for managers on equitable communication practices. Examining the underlying incentive structures for managers and the effectiveness of current performance review processes will be crucial in promoting a more supportive and growth-oriented workplace for all employees in the coming decade.
AI-generated to prompt reflection — not editorial opinion, not advice, not a statement of fact. How this works.